Recap: After Lily Bloom (no, she can’t believe that’s her name either) makes quite the statement — without saying anything much at all — at her father’s funeral, she decides to spend the evening on a Boston city rooftop. Just some alone time looking out over the city where she’s hoping to jumpstart her professional career. But that time is interrupted when a guy comes up to the rooftop, kicking chairs, angry, trying to work something out. When Lily and Ryle get to talking, sparks fly. While he insists on hooking up, Lily turns him down because she’s looking for more than just a hookup at this point.
But within months, the two start to run into each other and ultimately that spark between them can’t be ignored. Even Ryle, who was not looking for a relationship, is now hyper-invested in starting one with Lily. So the two go all in. All the while, Lily takes a professional leap from PR pro to business owner when she opens her own flower shop, the kind of meta passion project of hers that she knows sounds silly with a name like Lily Bloom, but which she also…could not ignore. She hires a woman who walks in off the street, and the two quickly become best friends. Allysa just so happens to be Ryle’s sister, so she and her husband, Marshall, Lily and Ryle quickly become an unstoppable foursome.
It all seems too good to be true. And it is. While all this is happening, Lily has been reading through some of her old journals from high school, reflecting on her first relationship with a boy named Atlas. He was homeless. Lily came from an abusive home. The two of them relied on each other for safety, love and support. So when Lily sees Atlas for the first time in years, working at a restaurant where she and Ryle are on a date, she is shocked to her core. At the same time, Ryle is starting to show some abusive patterns that are all too familiar to her childhood. All this forces Lily to rethink all the decision she’s made, leading her to this point.
Analysis: It Ends With Us is one of the more well-known and beloved Colleen Hoover books, and with good reason. It’s complicated and tackles the heavy issue of domestic abuse. While some praise Hoover for her handling of the topic, drawing from her own personal experience, others have crucified Hoover for “glorifying” abuse in relationships. Frankly, I don’t see her portrayal in the relationship between Lily and Ryle as glorified at all. (MAJOR SPOILER ALERT!!) She does ultimately make the right choice in leaving him, standing up for herself as hard as it is. It’s a bold move in a world where, unfortunately, many women statistically stay with their abusers.
What I found to be confusing is that Hoover takes a long time to get the reader to that point in the novel. I, like Lily, found myself initially on the fence about Ryle’s actions, wondering if he was truly a bad guy or not. That’s exactly Hoover’s point: to show how complicated it can to “read” an abuser and identify the best way to manage the situation. But I felt so much of the book was just a straight-up romance novel where everything is great! beautiful! perfect! sexy! that it didn’t feel realistic. Hoover takes a smidge too long getting to the crux of the the novel. But once she’s there, I couldn’t put the book down.
MVP: Allysa. She is fun, understanding and the perfect kind of a friend a girl could need with what Lily is dealing with in this heavy situation.