Recap: Charlie Reade is 17 years old and living in Illinois. He’s a teenager who has seen some serious trauma. His mom died when he was young, leading to his father’s long battle with alcoholism. But Charlie has figured out his life a bit. His dad is clean and sober, and Charlie is a star on the football team. Everything changes when one day, he happens to hear a man screaming near the creepy, old house in his neighborhood. It turns out Howard Bowditch has fallen and hurt himself. Charlie calls an ambulance to get Mr. Bowditch some help. As Mr. Bowditch heads to the hospital, Charlie takes on the responsibility of caring for Mr. Bowditch’s dog, Radar.
The first act of the becomes is a beautiful story of boy befriending dog followed by boy befriending dog’s crotchety, old owner. Charlie essentially gives up his entire life, quitting the football team and spending nights at Mr. Bowditch’s house to nurse him back to health and take care of Radar, who’s also nearing the end of his old dog life. But glimpses of fantasy start to creep in. Mr. Bowditch tasks Charlie with errands, like turning in hundreds of pellets of gold for cash to pay for his hospital bills. And the enormous creature in Mr. Bowditch’s shed that he kills one day.
When Mr. Bowditch eventually dies of a heart attack, Charlie listens to a tape from him that explains Mr. Bowditch is actually 120 years old and that his shed is a portal to another world, lying underground. He encourages Charlie to go there because it has a sundial that can turn back time and add years to your life, giving Charlie the opportunity to make Radar a young pup again.
Most of the rest of the novel takes place in the alternate world. A lot of time passes as Charlie learns more about Mr. Bowditch and commits to not only saving Radar but also saving the princess and all the “gray” people he meets. Charlie is on a mission to redeem himself for some of his young teen discretions, and in this fantasy coming-of-age novel, does exactly that.
Analysis: Stephen King takes this moment to write a story that doesn’t employ all of his usual storytelling factors. The story doesn’t take place in Maine. It’s not horror. And it has a pretty happy ending. (Actually, the epilogue is pretty awesome and satisfying.) Fairy Tale is a fun mix of genres, including a coming-of-age story with fantasy and fairy tales with a modern teen twist. It does become a little disjointed, however, due at least in part to its length and lead character, Charlie.
The book is 600 pages, which is fairly standard for King. The story is epic, so I can understand him wanting to keep the book long to parallel that epic-feeling, to beat into the reader that yes, this character is really going on a huge, life-changing journey. But somewhere halfway through the book, the first act with Mr. Bowditch starts to feel like it was an entirely separate story altogether. Although I personally loved the sweet story of Charlie and Mr. Bowditch, it’s really a precursor to the true story, which unfortunately doesn’t start until about 200 pages in. By that point, so much reality has been established that I found it hard to make the quick turn to pure fantasy. I found myself losing steam and speed reading just so I could get to the end with all the real feelings.
I also had a hard time understanding why Charlie would leave his father and entire world behind just for this dog that he’s known a few months. He keeps hinting at something “bad” he had done, and it’s clear that he’s on some sort of quest for salvation, but at the end, when the reader learns the bad thing he did, it didn’t really feel that bad. Therefore, his motivation for the entire journey doesn’t feel entirely unwarranted.
The writing is a little trite. While I enjoyed all the parallels and references to other already-existing fairy tales, I wish King wouldn’t have flat-out told us so many times. Part of the beauty of referencing other works is allowing the reader to find them and analyze them themselves. It’s less fun when the author is telling instead of showing.
But let’s be clear: it is a still a fun, fantastical story with a feel-good ending that made me smile. And I still liked it better than King’s Dolores Claiborne.
MVP: Charlie’s father. Though a pretty minor character, I loved the story of what he’s been through, what he overcame, and his reaction at the end of the book. He’s the hero for our story’s hero and sets an example for Charlie of the kind of man Charlie wants to and proves to be.